Sugaring Down Receives Kirkus Review
A novel welcomes readers to the late 1960s, when militant idealism flourished.
It’s the ’60s, and Vietnam War issues are roiling campuses; the Black Panthers are in the news; and a group of college kids, led by Jill Levy and David Levinski, has moved to an old farm in Vermont’s Northeast Kingdom. The cohorts will enjoy the simple life, hone their idealism, and plan protests. Fortunately, they have the farm’s wise, older former owners, Leland and Mary Smith, to befriend and ground them. The students squabble at times, and some townspeople are dangerously hostile, but they are surviving, making a go of it. Then Mark, a radicalized and charismatic Vietnam veteran, shows up and convinces Jill and others to bring the war home (think Weather Underground). David, wanting no part of such violence, stays on the farm. He is still there when Jill returns, on the run. The surprises come thick and fast in the dramatic climax. Chodorkoff is a very accomplished writer. The plot is strong, and the characters are well drawn. That said, Jill is also a recognizable type. She’s a daughter of privilege, with her father a well-known liberal lawyer and their Upper East Side apartment a Manhattan salon where they often entertain radicals. David, by contrast, is a middle-class kid lacking Jill’s overweening confidence and self-righteousness. It is all too easy to see how she could come to doubt and even ridicule David’s tentativeness and his ideological unease and how she could be seduced (literally and figuratively) by Mark, who is quick to save his own skin by giving her up to the feds. The author has David narrate most of the engrossing book, but the story is interspersed with Jill’s passages. She largely ruminates on her and David’s relationship and her ideological enthusiasms (and cluelessness). Along the way, readers will learn what year-round life is like in the Northeast Kingdom and the hard work and rewards of maple sugaring. And they will discover at the end that David is a real mensch. But they probably suspected that from the get-go.
A sensitive and engaging portrait of an important time and place.
